清华简《保训》篇真伪讨论中的文献辨伪方法论问题
——以姜广辉先生《< 保训>疑伪新证五则》为例
王连龙
提要:关于清华简《保训》的真伪问题,学界争讼已久。本文主要以姜广辉先生《< 保训>疑伪新证五则》所提出现代造伪说的五条新证据为例,从文献的载体、文辞、文法及思想内容等辨伪角度,对清华简《保训》篇真伪讨论中的文献辨伪方法论问题进行系统论述。
关键词:《保训》篇 清华简 辨伪
Title:On
the Methodological Problems Appeared in the Study of Part
Baoxun of the Bamboo Slips Collected by Ts’inghua
University: Centered with An Article by Mr. Jiang Guanghui
Author:Wang
Lianlong, Associate Professor, Institute for the Study of
Ancient Chinese Documents, Jilin University, Changchun,
Jilin, 130012, China
Abstract:Concerning the issue of real or fake of the partBaoxun(《保训》)
in the bamboo slips newly collected by the Ts’inghua
University, there has been a lasting debate. This paper,
focusing on the article by Mr. Jiang Guanghui(姜广辉)
entitled“Five
Evidences Related to the Questionable Points of the PartBaoxunin the Ts’inghua Collection of Bamboo Slips”(《< 保训>疑伪新证五则》),
provides different opinions from the aspects of the
material, language, grammar, idea, and contents of that part
of the Ts’inghua bamboo collection.
Key words:Baoxun
bamboo slip collection of Ts’inghua University real or fake